Don't waste your time.
Old mill has the rudest waitresses I’ve ever seen. Going there reminds me of the “Soup Nazi” episode on Seinfeld. Once they single you out for retribution, your goose is cooked. The only difference is the food is not that great.
Old Mill is great for old fashioned fun. There are great ice cream dishes for children with an old fashoined 1932 soda fountain. The best time to go are between 2:00 pm and close (3:00 pm). There is also a great breakfast served on Saturday mornings from 8:00 am to Noon that is a must if you love the food. Great wait staff and the owners are fantastic.